quote:
Originally posted by Ozman
1. Deads seem to involve a range of leg movement very similar to a squat, it's just the bar is held differently to involve much of the back as well. So isn't it similarly hard on your legs as a squat and not a 'secondary' leg exercise?
Deadlifts are not similarly hard on your legs. Squats tax the legs much more. All I can tell you is that I've never had a trainee have a problem with squatting on Friday and deadlifting on Monday OR squatting on Monday and deadliftng on Friday. As I mentioned before, you're only doing 5 work sets. That shouldn't create a problem.
But if you find that your legs take a long time to recover, then squat on Monday and deadlift on Friday. Conversely, some guys claim that their posterior chain is sore for many days after deadlifting and it impedes their ability to squat, so for them deadlifting on Monday and squatting on Friday is the way to go.
quote:
2. If you are squatting and doing the other leg set on Friday it is only three days until Monday, when you do the deads. 3 days is not enough recovery for a body part (legs in this case) according to just about everything I read, which says a week is the best. I know it's not enough for me, cos I am just losing the soreness by then.
First of all, there's no such thing as only working a muscle once a week. Even if you only "work" each muscle once a week with "direct" exercises, it is in fact impossible not to work each muscle 2 or 3 times a week. Take shoulders for example. Yes, you may only train shoulders once a week on PUSH day, but when you deadlift, you work your shoulders. When you squat, you work your shoulders. Likewise, you may only train lats once a week on PULL day, but when you bench, your lats get killed. This is true for every muscle. My point here is that it's impossible to train each muscle only once a week, so don't get too caught up in limiting working each muscle to once a week unless you intend to have only one monster workout a week.
About the Friday to Monday issue. The difference here is that you are deadlifting after not having touched a weight for 72 hours. Not only are your legs almost 100% recovered, but more importantly, your central nervous system is well rested. Even if you still have a little soreness in your legs, deadlifting is not going to have any negative effects.
All this being said, it seems that the best course of action for you is to squat on Monday and deadlift on Friday.